top of page
E978C01D-9589-48D3-9775-EF6F9DEF9829.png

Charlotte Seeks Dismissal Of Iryna Zarutska Wrongful Death Suit

7 minutes ago
1 min read

Charlotte is asking a judge to dismiss the wrongful death lawsuit brought by Iryna Zarutska’s estate, arguing governmental immunity protects the city from claims that inadequate transit security contributed to her killing.


The city filed its response Nov. 16 in Mecklenburg County Superior Court. It acknowledges that no private security guard was inside Zarutska’s train car during the attack, Fox News Digital reported.


Zarutska, a 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee, was fatally stabbed aboard the Charlotte Area Transit System’s Lynx Blue Line Aug. 22, 2025. Decarlos Brown Jr. faces state and federal charges in her death.


Her uncle and estate administrator, Frank Scott Haskell, sued Charlotte and its security contractor, Professional Police Services, doing business as Professional Security Services, Aug. 21.


The lawsuit alleges stronger fare enforcement, entry barriers, and adequate security staffing could have prevented her death. The estate argues Charlotte cannot claim immunity for operating a fare-collecting transit system, which it characterizes as a business activity.

Charlotte argues in its response that policing, crime prevention, and security oversight are governmental functions protected under state law.


“The City denies that it ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack,” its attorneys wrote. They said the transit system contracted for armed and unarmed security before the killing.


City attorneys dispute that earlier transit crimes made this attack reasonably foreseeable or that staffing and fare-enforcement decisions legally caused it.

If claims proceed, Charlotte is asking the court to limit its liability to $1 million under the state law it cites.


No ruling had been reported as of Nov. 20. A judge will determine whether some or all claims against Charlotte can move forward.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page